StudyMoose App
24/7 writing help on your phone
Save to my list
Remove from my list
Shakespeare is renowned for various literary accomplishments, with his sonnets standing out prominently. Among the plethora of sonnets, two gems, Sonnet 116 and Sonnet 130, shine with distinct techniques and nuances. This essay delves into a detailed comparison of these poetic marvels, exploring their structure, rhyme schemes, and the vivid imagery employed by the bard.
Both Sonnet 116 and Sonnet 130 adhere to the traditional sonnet structure, comprising three quatrains and a rhyming couplet, amounting to fourteen lines in total.
The rhyme scheme follows the pattern ABAB for the first quatrain, CDCD for the second, EFEF for the third, and GG for the final rhyming couplet. It is noteworthy that in Sonnet 116, the B's are eye rhymes, while the F's are imperfect rhymes, adding a layer of complexity to the rhyme scheme. The consistent use of iambic pentameter, a hallmark of Shakespearean sonnets, contributes to the rhythmic flow of the poems, engaging the reader with its distinctive stressed and unstressed syllables.
5 (234)
“ Very organized ,I enjoyed and Loved every bit of our professional interaction ”
Both sonnets are adorned with vivid imagery, captivating the reader's senses. In Sonnet 116, lines 5 to 8 paint a celestial scene of an "ever fixed mark" guiding a ship through tempests, while Sonnet 130 employs imagery in line 4, comparing the mistress's hair to "black wires." Shakespeare masterfully utilizes imagery to appeal not only to the visual senses but also to the kinesthetic senses, as seen in Sonnet 130, where readers can imagine the tactile qualities of the described hair.
It is noteworthy that while Sonnet 116 employs more imagery, Sonnet 130's imagery possesses deeper, often paradoxical meanings.
This nuanced approach enhances the overall impact of the poems, leaving readers with lasting impressions.
Shakespeare employs assonance and alliteration to enhance the sonic quality of the sonnets. In Sonnet 116, the first line showcases examples of alliteration with "Let me not to the marriage of true minds," where the repeated consonant sounds of 'm' create a melodic effect. Additionally, assonance is subtly intertwined with the alliteration, as exemplified by the words "me," "marriage," and "minds."
Contrastingly, Sonnet 130 incorporates these devices sparingly, with a sole instance in the line "But no such roses see I in her cheeks." The purpose here is to provide a rhythmic flow, enhancing the overall auditory experience. In Sonnet 116, assonance serves a dual purpose by incorporating onomatopoeia in the phrase "Within his bending sickle's compass come," appealing to the auditory senses with the evocation of the Grim Reaper's sickle.
Repetition, a prominent poetic device, finds its place in Sonnet 116, where the words "love" and "alter" are reiterated for emphasis. This repetition not only strengthens the thematic elements but also contributes to the memorability of the poem. The absence of repetition in Sonnet 130 emphasizes a different stylistic choice, allowing the unique qualities of each sonnet to shine independently.
Shakespeare employs enjambment in both sonnets, strategically breaking sentences across lines. In Sonnet 116, the phrase "love is not love - Which alters when it alteration finds" demonstrates this technique, maintaining adherence to iambic pentameter while providing a nuanced pacing. Similarly, Sonnet 130 employs enjambment in line 7, with "And in some perfumes is there more delight - Than in the breath that from my mistress reeks." This deliberate use shapes the reader's experience, creating pauses and influencing the interpretative rhythm.
Metaphors and similes play a pivotal role in Shakespearean sonnets, establishing profound comparisons. In Sonnet 116, the metaphor "O, no it is an ever fixed-mark" likens love to an unwavering celestial entity, while Sonnet 130 compares the mistress's hair to "wires" in a simile. These comparisons, though more abundant in Sonnet 116, contribute to the nuanced beauty of both sonnets, offering readers distinct perspectives on love and beauty.
Sonnet 116 introduces a paradox in its concluding line, asserting that if the poet is proven wrong, he "never writ, nor no man ever loved." This paradox serves a dual purpose, highlighting the impossibility of the poet never having written while also appealing to the relatable experience of falling in love. Sonnet 130, devoid of this particular device, maintains its own unique charm, relying on unconventional descriptions to captivate its audience.
Both sonnets culminate with a rhyming couplet, a signature feature in Shakespearean sonnets. This serves as the punch line, delivering profound messages that linger in the reader's mind. The concluding lines of the sonnets not only encapsulate the essence of the poems but also contribute to their memorability, ensuring a lasting impact on the audience.
Beyond the structural and poetic elements, Sonnet 116 delves into profound themes of platonic love. The poem establishes an idealized portrayal of love that transcends external influences and remains steadfast amidst challenges. The celestial imagery of an "ever fixed mark" symbolizes an enduring and unwavering commitment, providing readers with a timeless perspective on the purity of true love.
The use of alliteration in the opening line, "Let me not to the marriage of true minds," reinforces the unity of like-minded souls bound by the sanctity of marriage. The repetition of the word "love" throughout the poem serves as a rhythmic refrain, underscoring the central theme and imprinting it in the reader's memory.
While Sonnet 116 explores lofty ideals of love, Sonnet 130 takes a satirical approach to conventional beauty standards. The poet playfully dismantles the traditional Petrarchan conventions, where the mistress is idealized with exaggerated comparisons. Instead, Shakespeare opts for honesty and authenticity in describing his mistress, debunking the conventional norms of beauty prevalent in his era.
The paradoxical nature of the poem lies in its straightforward and unidealized depiction of the mistress. Lines like "My mistress' eyes are nothing like the sun" and "And in some perfumes is there more delight - Than in the breath that from my mistress reeks" challenge societal norms, offering a refreshing and unconventional take on love and beauty.
Considering the historical context adds a layer of understanding to Shakespeare's artistic choices. In the 16th and 17th centuries, when these sonnets were composed, Shakespeare was not the literary giant we perceive him as today. His audience may not have been aware of the extensive body of work he would eventually produce. Hence, the inclusion of relatable themes like love and the use of paradox in Sonnet 116 served a dual purpose — engaging the audience's emotions and leaving a lasting imprint that resonated with their own experiences.
The rhyming couplet at the conclusion of both sonnets emerges as a powerful tool in shaping the legacy of Shakespeare's work. Beyond its role as a poetic device, the rhyming couplet serves as the ultimate revelation, encapsulating the core message of each sonnet. In Sonnet 116, the declaration that if proven wrong, the poet "never writ, nor no man ever loved" not only introduces a paradox but also asserts the poet's commitment to the authenticity of his words.
Similarly, in Sonnet 130, the rhyming couplet concludes with a humorous and poignant twist, challenging conventional notions of beauty with the declaration that the mistress is rare and unique in her own right. This deliberate choice to end on a memorable note enhances the impact of both sonnets, leaving an indelible mark on the reader's consciousness.
In conclusion, the exploration of Sonnet 116 and Sonnet 130 reveals not only the technical brilliance of Shakespeare but also the timeless nature of his themes. Sonnet 116 unveils the essence of platonic love, while Sonnet 130 challenges societal norms with a satirical take on beauty. The meticulous use of poetic devices, the exploration of profound themes, and the strategic placement of the rhyming couplet all contribute to the enduring beauty of these sonnets.
As readers traverse the intricacies of Shakespeare's verses, they are transported to an era where love, beauty, and authenticity were as relevant as they are today. The sonnets continue to captivate hearts, showcasing the enduring legacy of a literary maestro whose words transcend time.
Exploring Shakespearean Sonnets: A Comparative Analysis. (2021, Sep 30). Retrieved from https://studymoose.com/similarities-and-differences-in-the-use-of-poetic-techniques-in-william-shakespeare-s-sonnet-116-and-sonnet-130-essay
👋 Hi! I’m your smart assistant Amy!
Don’t know where to start? Type your requirements and I’ll connect you to an academic expert within 3 minutes.
get help with your assignment
