The Homogeneity of American Communities: A Reflection

In his essay "People Like Us", Brooks argues that while America may be diverse as a whole, individual communities are often homogeneous. He highlights various ways in which Americans tend to separate themselves from one another. I personally agree with Brooks' points and can see similarities in my own life, particularly when it comes to the racial homogenization of towns and cities.

In his book "People Like Us", Brooks starts off by providing instances of how individuals tend to segregate themselves.

While many associate diversity with race, Brooks expands this concept to include geographical, cultural, and occupational diversity. People have a knack for pinpointing even the most minor distinctions between themselves and others. In fact, these differences often influence major decisions in their lives. This constant emphasis on subtle variations leads us to gravitate towards individuals who are increasingly similar to us, resulting in certain communities embodying specific traits and characteristics.

Brooks notes that our cities and neighborhoods are increasingly homogenous, as places become synonymous with certain qualities that only reinforce their existing identities.

Get quality help now

Marrie pro writer

Verified writer

Proficient in: Society

5 (204)

“ She followed all my directions. It was really easy to contact her and respond very fast as well. ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

This process is not seen as a negative outcome to be prevented; rather, Brooks argues that people actually embrace this segmentation, finding comfort and happiness in being surrounded by those they perceive as similar to themselves.

Brooks points out that despite efforts for racial integration, there is a trend towards increasing segregation. Despite long-standing efforts to combat housing discrimination, people of different races are opting to live apart from each other. This self-segregation based on race leads to certain areas being associated with specific racial groups, reinforcing stereotypes and further entrenching segregation.

Brooks further reinforces his concept by illustrating how geographic location can separate us into different demographics. Various companies guide entrepreneurs to target specific areas for marketing based on the characteristics of the residents. The ease with which we can be categorized into these groups is highlighted by Brooks, emphasizing our inclination to align with like-minded individuals.

Brooks further elaborates on how individuals divide themselves not only by small distinctions, race, and location but also by their personal histories. People tend to form cliques based on factors such as education or social status. If someone shares a similar background with you, there is a greater likelihood of wanting to associate with them. Past experiences play a significant role in attracting people to each other.

David Brooks argues that despite claiming to value diversity, elite universities in America are actually some of the least diverse places. He points out that faculty members at these institutions are predominantly liberal, undermining the universities' professed commitment to diversity.

Brooks expresses worry about how we tend to segregate ourselves with those who are similar to us. He notes that by immersing ourselves in communities that mirror our own characteristics, we miss out on different perspectives. Our own thoughts and values become further entrenched.

In his essay, Brooks makes several points that I agree with. I personally can relate to his observation that we tend to stick to people of our own race instead of diversifying our social circles. Growing up in Independence, Iowa, with a population of around five thousand, most of whom were white, I rarely encountered people of different races. The only minority in my class was a Mexican boy with immigrant parents. Despite the lack of racial diversity in my town, I never questioned why this was the case.

When I was in fifth grade, a black family moved into town and their son was placed in my class. Despite living in the same neighborhood and participating in the same activities, we soon became friends. However, witnessing the discrimination and intolerance towards my friend due to his race opened my eyes to the prevailing attitude in our predominantly white community. My friend was often targeted by his peers at school and even faced racial slurs when we walked down the street. These incidents forced me to confront the reality that our community was intentionally homogenous, as many residents chose to live there because of a shared discomfort with people of different races. The presence of my friend and his family disrupted their sense of security and comfort, highlighting the underlying prejudices within our community.

They introduced new experiences, ideas, and lifestyles that were different from their own. Waterloo, Iowa, a city located roughly twenty minutes away from me, was known in my area as the "black town" due to its large black community. When my friend and his family moved there during my sophomore year of high school, they cited job opportunities as the reason. However, after reading Brooks' essay, I now wonder if the sentiments he described played a role in their decision. Perhaps they moved to Waterloo because it had a reputation for being a place where people similar to them resided. This aligns with Brooks' point about how places known for a particular race tend to reinforce those stereotypes.

In my opinion, Brooks' observations regarding our natural inclination to associate with like-minded individuals are accurate and applicable to my own experiences. His insights offer valuable explanations for various aspects of our lives, prompting us to consider whether we are content with living in such homogeneous environments. While Brooks suggests that our tendencies for homogeneity may be difficult to change, he proposes that we strive to engage in more diverse experiences. Ultimately, I believe that many of us prefer the comfort of familiar, homogenized communities, hindering our progress towards becoming a truly integrated and diverse society.