Annie Dillard: Nature's Role in Suffering

Introduction

Annie Dillard, a celebrated essayist and Pulitzer Prize winner of 1975, has left an indelible mark in the literary world with works such as Teaching a Stone to Talk (1982), An American Childhood (1987), and The Writing Life (1989). In her compelling essay, "The Deer of Providence," Dillard emerges as both a skilled writer and a nature enthusiast, exploring the mysteries and excitement inherent in new natural environments (Dillard).

The central theme of Dillard's narrative revolves around the inevitability of suffering as a natural phenomenon.

Through her experiences as the only woman among four North American travelers in the Amazon jungle, she unveils a shocking event involving a deer ensnared by village dogs in Providence. This incident serves as a lens through which Dillard examines the nature of pain and suffering, urging individuals to acknowledge and cope with these realities rather than dwell on their occurrence.

The Deer of Providence: Nature's Indifference to Suffering

As the youngest and sole female in the group, Annie Dillard and her companions witness a distressing scene in Providence—a captured deer with injuries on its thin neck, struggling against the entanglement of a rope tied to three of its hooves.

Get quality help now

WriterBelle

Verified writer

Proficient in: Free Essays

4.7 (657)

“ Really polite, and a great writer! Task done as described and better, responded to all my questions promptly too! ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

The group later partakes in a meal comprising well-prepared fish, a previously caught deer, rice, and bananas, all while Dillard's apparent lack of remorse for the deer intrigues her male companions.

Dillard reflects on a picture in her bathroom back home, depicting a man who had endured the burning of his face for the second time in his life.

This recollection becomes a pivotal moment, unveiling Dillard's underlying theme: pain and suffering, whether experienced by humans or animals, are inherent aspects of nature (Dillard, 1945).

Supporting the Thesis: Comparative Analysis

To bolster her thesis, Dillard draws on two poignant examples—the struggle of the Deer of Providence and the story of Mr. McDonald, a man featured in a newspaper article who endured the burning of his face. Despite differences in circumstances, these illustrations converge on the central idea that suffering is an indiscriminate force in nature.

The first distinction lies in the cause of suffering. In the case of the Deer of Providence, it is the actions of other creatures, namely the dogs and humans, that inflict pain and suffering on the deer. In contrast, Mr. McDonald's suffering is a result of a pure accident with no one to blame. Another disparity emerges in the aftermath of suffering; while the deer faces an inevitable death, Mr. McDonald has a chance of survival, as evidenced by his previous burning experience (Dillard, 1945).

However, these differences do not diminish the core similarity—both instances cause pain and suffering to those involved. Whether the suffering is a consequence of the actions of other creatures or an accident, and regardless of the survival outcome, the fundamental purpose of Dillard's illustrations is to underscore the ubiquity of pain and suffering in the natural world.

Persuasive Narrative and Personal Reflection

Annie Dillard masterfully articulates her thesis, employing persuasive arguments supported by personal experiences in both the jungle and the comfort of her home. Her conviction in the universality of suffering, whether observed in the wild or within the confines of human society, resonates with the reader, compelling a contemplation of nature's impartial role in the existence of pain and hardship.

Conclusion

Annie Dillard's exploration of suffering in "The Deer of Providence" offers a profound perspective on the intrinsic nature of pain. Through vivid storytelling and careful analysis, she asserts that suffering is an undeniable part of the natural order, affecting both humans and animals alike. As readers, we are challenged to confront and accept the inevitability of suffering, transcending individual circumstances and acknowledging the broader canvas of nature's indifference. Dillard's essay stands as a testament to the enduring power of nature to shape our understanding of the world and our place within it.