The Enigmatic Bartleby: A Tale of Passivity and Adaptation

Herman Melville's literary creation, "Bartleby the Scrivener," penned in 1853, serves as a profound exploration of the evolving attitudes towards work during the throes of industrialization. This work intricately weaves together the lives of two contrasting characters, Bartleby and the narrator, offering a glimpse into the challenges of adapting to a society undergoing rapid transformation. As we unravel the allegorical threads binding Bartleby to the zeitgeist of the era, we also delve into the intriguing parallels drawn between Bartleby and Melville's illustrious character, Moby Dick.

The Disparity in Adaptation

Melville ingeniously unfolds the narrative, showcasing the stark differences between Bartleby and the narrator, echoing the broader societal divide of those embracing the industrial revolution and those clinging to traditional norms. Bartleby, portrayed as a lost soul, navigates the bustling world of Wall Street with a palpable reluctance to conform. In stark contrast, the narrator seamlessly integrates into this dynamic environment, symbolizing the dichotomy between the old and the new. The exploration of character intricacies, plot dynamics, and the vibrant setting serves to highlight the antithetical relationship, emblematic of the societal rift.

Get quality help now
checked Verified writer

Proficient in: Free Essays

star star star star 4.7 (657)

“ Really polite, and a great writer! Task done as described and better, responded to all my questions promptly too! ”

avatar avatar avatar
+84 relevant experts are online
Hire writer

Bartleby and Moby Dick: A Comparative Analysis

Literary scholars, delving into the depths of Melville's narrative, draw intriguing parallels between Bartleby and the iconic character, Moby Dick. Mark Elliott, an esteemed authority, propounds that both characters function as metaphorical "walls," symbolizing Melville's skepticism regarding humanity's capacity to comprehend and control universal forces. Bartleby's enigmatic persona and his recurring refrain, "I would prefer not to," stand as a testament to his unyielding resistance to societal norms, leading the narrator on a journey of frustration and near madness.

Get to Know The Price Estimate For Your Paper
Number of pages
Email Invalid email

By clicking “Check Writers’ Offers”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy policy. We’ll occasionally send you promo and account related email

"You must agree to out terms of services and privacy policy"
Write my paper

You won’t be charged yet!

The Unyielding Wall of Bartleby

Bartleby's wants and needs remain elusive to the narrator, intensifying the latter's obsession with understanding this mysterious character. Melville strategically employs the motif of Bartleby's refusal, emphasizing his unwavering resistance to conformity. The bustling setting of Wall Street serves as a poignant backdrop, accentuating the stark disparity between Bartleby's character and the frenetic pace of the environment. While the narrator effortlessly adapts to this world, Bartleby's status as an outsider becomes increasingly apparent, reinforcing the disjunct unity between the two characters.

The Subtle Humor of Parallels

Adding a layer of nuanced humor to the narrative, Melville unveils the narrator's obliviousness to the striking similarities shared with Bartleby. Confined to their respective spaces, both characters exhibit traits of inaction and an aversion to confrontation. The narrator, despite perceiving himself as a man of action, fails to recognize his inherent passivity. This starkly contrasts with Bartleby's radical passivity, a concept that Todd Giles interprets as a manifestation of freedom and selfhood.

Pitying the Unaware Narrator

Giles argues persuasively that it is the narrator, not Bartleby, who warrants pity. While Bartleby embraces his passivity as a form of affirmation and life embracement, the narrator remains blissfully unaware of his own passivity, erroneously considering himself a man of action. This subtle irony functions as a profound commentary on human nature and society, forcing readers to confront the intricacies of societal perceptions and self-awareness.

The Ambiguity of Bartleby's Character

Melville, a master of literary craftsmanship, intentionally fashions Bartleby as an enigmatic character, inviting readers to explore a myriad of interpretations. The story transcends a mere exploration of individual characters, becoming a profound statement on the complexity of human nature. In mirroring the diverse emotions and attitudes present in society, Bartleby's character defies a unified theory, leaving readers grappling with the enigma Melville intended.

Further Exploration: Melville's Societal Commentary

Beyond the individual character dynamics, "Bartleby the Scrivener" emerges as a multi-faceted exploration of societal adaptation and the intricate fabric of human existence. Melville employs a rich tapestry of literary elements to delve into the broader implications of societal change. The narrative invites readers to contemplate the nuanced interplay between passivity and adaptation, prompting a deeper reflection on the intricacies of human behavior during times of societal upheaval.

The Symbolism of Wall Street

Wall Street, a bustling and dynamic setting, assumes a symbolic role in the narrative, representing the epitome of industrial progress. Bartleby's incongruity within this environment serves as a poignant commentary on the challenges faced by individuals amidst rapid societal transformation. Conversely, the narrator's seamless integration into Wall Street mirrors the adaptability of those who readily embrace the changing times. The dichotomy between these two characters serves as a microcosm of the larger societal struggles during this era.

Unveiling Bartleby's Wisdom

In a surprising turn of interpretation, some critics argue that Bartleby, in his refusal to take a definitive stance, emerges as the wiser of the two characters. His refusal, epitomized by the recurring phrase "I would prefer not to," becomes a manifestation of unconfined freedom. Todd Giles challenges readers to view Bartleby's "radical passivity" as unrepentantly affirmative and life-embracing, positioning Bartleby as a figure embodying the full force of potentiality. In contrast, the narrator's perceived unconfined existence becomes a façade, revealing a character constrained by his own perceptions and societal expectations.

Reconsidering Pity: The Unaware Narrator

As readers delve deeper into the layers of Melville's narrative, the question of pity takes a compelling turn. Perhaps, it is the unaware narrator who deserves our empathy. While Bartleby navigates the realm of radical passivity with a sense of liberation, the narrator remains oblivious to his own passive existence. This revelation prompts a reevaluation of the subtle irony embedded in the narrative and encourages readers to empathize with the narrator's unwitting journey towards self-awareness.

The Grand Statement on Society

In its essence, the story of Bartleby transcends individual character studies, evolving into a grand statement on society and human nature. Melville, with his keen understanding of human complexities, crafts a narrative that mirrors the multifaceted nature of society. The narrative becomes a canvas on which readers paint their interpretations, mirroring the diversity of thought and emotion that permeates the human experience.

Concluding Reflections

In conclusion, "Bartleby the Scrivener" stands as a timeless exploration of societal adaptation, individual passivity, and the intricate dance between human nature and societal expectations. Melville's narrative brilliance unfolds in layers, inviting readers to unravel the symbolic richness embedded in characters, setting, and plot. The enigmatic Bartleby becomes a muse, challenging readers to confront the complexities of their own existence and

Written by Mia Hernandez
Updated: Jan 18, 2024
Keep in mind: this is only a sample!
Updated: Jan 18, 2024
Cite this page

The Enigmatic Bartleby: A Tale of Passivity and Adaptation. (2022, Feb 04). Retrieved from

The Enigmatic Bartleby: A Tale of Passivity and Adaptation essay
Live chat  with support 24/7

👋 Hi! I’m your smart assistant Amy!

Don’t know where to start? Type your requirements and I’ll connect you to an academic expert within 3 minutes.

get help with your assignment