Exploring Class and Character Contrasts in The Great Gatsby

F. Scott Fitzgerald's novel, The Great Gatsby, delves into the complex world of the American upper class during the Roaring Twenties, revealing stark differences in character, values, and social standing between two central figures: Tom Buchanan and Jay Gatsby. Through the lens of the narrator, Nick Carraway, this essay will examine the contrasting attributes of Tom and Gatsby, highlighting the theme of class and its impact on their lives.

The Power of Wealth and Superficiality

Tom Buchanan, a character emblematic of old money and privilege, exemplifies the practicality of using wealth as a means of impressing others, particularly his wife, Daisy.

Tom's wealth allows him to maintain a lavish lifestyle, complete with a sprawling mansion and extravagant parties, all designed to showcase his affluence. He understands that in the world he inhabits, material possessions and opulence can serve as a means to gain influence and command respect.

This practical approach to life is exemplified in Tom's extramarital affair with Myrtle Wilson.

Get quality help now

RhizMan

Verified writer

Proficient in: Books And Reading

4.9 (247)

“ Rhizman is absolutely amazing at what he does . I highly recommend him if you need an assignment done ”

+84 relevant experts are online

Hire writer

Tom's wealth affords him the ability to maintain a New York apartment for this illicit relationship, demonstrating how he leverages his resources for personal gratification without much thought to the moral consequences. His wealth serves as a tool for indulging in his desires, an avenue to acquire what he desires, regardless of the impact on others.

In stark contrast, Jay Gatsby's pursuit of wealth and status is driven by a deeper longing - his love for Daisy Buchanan. Gatsby, born into modest circumstances, is the epitome of the self-made man, engaging in various illicit activities to amass a fortune.

His immense wealth is a means to an end, a way to bridge the social chasm that separates him from Daisy, who symbolizes the unattainable American Dream.

Unlike Tom, whose wealth is an inherent part of his identity, Gatsby's riches are a vehicle for him to rewrite his past and create a future with Daisy. He uses his opulent mansion and extravagant parties not only to impress Daisy but also to craft an illusion of grandeur that he believes will win her back. Gatsby's approach to wealth is a manifestation of his relentless pursuit of a dream, a dream rooted in love and longing.

The Superficiality of Relationships

Another facet of the characters' contrasts lies in the superficiality of their relationships. For Tom and Daisy, their marriage represents a union of convenience rather than a deep emotional connection. The Buchanans are absorbed in their own shallow worlds, where material comfort and social status take precedence over genuine affection. Nick Carraway observes their marriage, noting, "They weren't happy... and yet they weren't unhappy either. There was an unmistakable air of natural intimacy about the picture, and anybody would have said that they were conspiring together" (Fitzgerald 152).

Tom and Daisy's relationship is transactional, their lives intertwined primarily for societal convenience. Their wealth affords them the luxury of ignoring the emotional chasms in their marriage, maintaining a façade of contentment. Their lives are a testament to the idea that money can serve as a powerful adhesive, even in the absence of genuine love or compatibility.

On the other hand, Jay Gatsby's relationship with Daisy is characterized by profound emotional investment. His love for her is all-encompassing and unwavering, a driving force that fuels his relentless pursuit of success and wealth. Gatsby's parties and extravagance are not mere displays of opulence; they are his attempts to recapture a lost love.

Despite their separation and Daisy's marriage to Tom, Gatsby holds onto the belief that their love is timeless and unbreakable. His dedication to Daisy is reflected in Nick Carraway's reflection on Gatsby: "Gatsby turned out all right in the end; it is what preyed on Gatsby, what foul dust floated in the wake of his dreams that temporarily closed out my interest in the abortive sorrows and short-winded elations of men" (Fitzgerald 8). Gatsby's unwavering commitment to his dream of love sets him apart from the superficiality of the Buchanans' relationship.

The Moral Divide

The moral disparity between Tom and Gatsby is another striking contrast in their characters. Nick Carraway, the novel's narrator, offers his assessment of Tom's character, portraying him as an individual who is willing to exploit and harm others for personal gain. Nick's disillusionment with Tom's morality is evident when he states, "They were careless people, Tom and Daisy—they smashed up things and creatures and then retreated back into their money or their vast carelessness, or whatever it was that kept them together, and let other people clean up the mess they had made" (Fitzgerald 186).

Tom's cold-hearted and destructive disposition is evident in his actions, such as covering up the truth about Daisy's involvement in Myrtle Wilson's death, which ultimately leads to tragic consequences. His willingness to prioritize self-preservation over the well-being of others underscores his moral bankruptcy.

In contrast, Jay Gatsby's moral compass is portrayed differently. While his pursuit of wealth involves questionable activities, his ultimate goal is driven by love rather than self-interest. Gatsby's relentless dedication to Daisy is an indication of his capacity for genuine emotion and vulnerability. Nick's opinion of Gatsby evolves throughout the novel, culminating in his heartfelt tribute: "They're a rotten crowd [Nick, Daisy, and Jordan]... You're worth the whole damn bunch put together" (Fitzgerald 160).

Nick's words underscore his growing disdain for the moral hollowness of Tom and his subtle acknowledgment of Gatsby's virtues. Gatsby, despite his flaws, is ultimately viewed by Nick as a more complex and redeemable character than the morally bankrupt Tom.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the juxtaposition of Tom Buchanan and Jay Gatsby serves as a central theme in F. Scott Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby, providing insights into the complexities of class and character. The 1920s, a period marked by rapid economic growth and societal change, witnessed individuals like Gatsby striving to attain wealth and status, either through inherited privilege or self-made success.

The contrasting personas of Tom and Gatsby highlight the divergent paths to wealth and success, shedding light on the power dynamics of the era. While Tom embodies the ease of acquiring status through birthright and utilizes wealth as a tool for personal indulgence, Gatsby represents the relentless pursuit of dreams, driven by love and ambition.

Moreover, the superficiality of relationships and the moral dichotomy between the two characters further emphasize their differences. Tom and Daisy Buchanan's marriage is a union of convenience, sustained by their shared materialism, while Gatsby's unwavering love for Daisy transcends societal conventions.

Nick Carraway's evolving perspective on the characters underscores the moral disparity, ultimately positioning Gatsby as a more complex and sympathetic figure than Tom.

The Great Gatsby invites readers to reflect on the intricate interplay of wealth, character, and morality in the pursuit of the American Dream. Through the contrasting fates of Tom Buchanan and Jay Gatsby, the novel prompts us to question the nature of success and the price one is willing to pay for it.

As we navigate our own journeys in a world shaped by ambition and aspiration, the lessons drawn from these characters continue to resonate, challenging us to consider the paths we choose and the values we uphold in our pursuit of our own versions of the green light on the horizon.