Should assisted suicide be legalised
Should assisted suicide be legalised
Euthanasia is a broad term for mercy killing, taking the life of a hopelessly ill or injured person in order to end his or her suffering. Mercy killing represents a serious ethical dilemma. But euthanasia seems to contradict one of the most basic rules of life, which is that killing is wrong. Viewed from a traditional Christian point of view, euthanasia is murder and a violation of the bibles commandment “Thou shalt not kill. ” Euthanasia is so controversial because it pits the light of suffering, dying individuals against religious beliefs, legal tradition, and, in the case of doctor -assisted death, medical ethics.
It has been argued that euthanasia is one of the most social concerns of our time. A review of up to date scientific materials, however indicates that this issue is complex and crosses many perspectives. Should euthanasia be legalised? Many are strong headed about their opinion on this matter; there are many celebrities who are for and against it. ”My life is miserable, demeaning and undignified” Says locked-in syndrome sufferer Mr Tony Nicklinson as he asked the high court judges to give him the right to die.
Significantly he claims that the current law happens to be “anomalous and discriminatory” and has not stopped the “widespread practice of euthanasia. ” Arguments for and against euthanasia came to head last year when Tony Nickonson and his family approached the court asking for his right to die the way he wanted to. This brought out a lot of strong opinions from some very tolerable people, and some reasons people want euthanasia to be legalised are, one the fact that it is cruel and inhumane to refuse someone the right to die, when they are suffering from an unstoppable pain or disease.
Two is that euthanasia should be allowed when it is in the best interests of all involved and does not violate anyone’s rights. As euthanasia is such a wide spread topic with many different opinions there are also arguments against euthanasia being legalised. As the Dutch experience reveals, euthanasia doctors tend to be uninterested in actually caring for their patients and see it at easier to administer euthanasia than learning of different ways or techniques of caring for the dying.
It may also give improper power to doctors: Voluntary euthanasia gives power which can be too easily abused. Doctors need the law to restrain the temptation to speed up dying for the terminally ill and awkward patients. There is also a significant amount of pressure on the elderly; the “right to die” can become a duty to die. Old people can be made to feel a burden on their families. Health insurers and hospital managers find euthanasia far cheaper than extended medical care.
Another case in favour of ‘mercy killing’ came to head about two mean both aged 45, named Marc and Eddy Verbessem, from the village of Putte, near the city of Mechelen, were born deaf and asked for a mercy killing after finding out that they would also soon go blind. Dirk Verbessem, 46, explained that his younger siblings had lived together for all there adolescent life and did not have the ability to communicate with the outside world. “Their great fear was that they would no longer be able to see each other. That was for my brothers unbearable,” he said.
The deaf twin brothers had spent their entire lives together, sharing a flat while both working as cobblers and could only communicate with special sign language understood by each other and their immediate family. More people have views on euthanasia and some people think that euthanasia happens anyway, so it’s better to have it out in the open so that it can be properly regulated and carried out. While some other people think that this is a highly technical argument, and it’s only relevant to people who accept that passive euthanasia is sometimes right.
And even the Star Treck actor Sir Patrick Stewart, who apart from being diagnosed with coronary heart disease a number of years ago is a healthy age, suddenly announced he wanted to be allowed an assisted death. Above all euthanasia violates accepted codes of medical ethics: the Hippocratic Oath, the World Medical Association in its 1992 statement of Marbella, more recently NZ Medical Association, commended euthanasia as unethical. The public also believes that the law is a powerful educator of their conscience.
People tend to have strong feelings once a practice becomes legal and widely accepted. The Nazi euthanasia programme revealed the desensitising of those involved. All in all euthanasia is an extremely dispersed topic with many views which usually end up turning into heated debates. After looking at both sides of the argument, should assisted suicide be legalised? Yes I think it should, going back to one of the points I mentioned earlier, if people want to die because they are erminally ill, or there is just simply no way possible they can function anymore and they are going to die painfully then yes, they should be able to make that decision on their own and if euthanasia is what they decide, then it should be allowed, make it a dying persons last wish I say. Although I don’t judge people who think euthanasia should stay illegal, it is completely up to them what they think, but I will disagree every time, euthanasia should be completely legal in my opinion.
University/College: University of Chicago
Type of paper: Thesis/Dissertation Chapter
Date: 28 September 2016
We will write a custom essay sample on Should assisted suicide be legalised
for only $16.38 $12.9/page