Comparative Analysis of Shakespearean Sonnets

Categories: William Shakespeare

William Shakespeare, renowned for his poetic prowess, has left an indelible mark on the literary landscape with his exquisite sonnets. This essay embarks on a comparative analysis of two of his most celebrated sonnets, Sonnet 18 - 'Shall I compare thee...' and Sonnet 116 - 'Let me not.' Although both delve into the realm of love, each sonnet navigates this vast territory with a unique perspective, audience, and purpose.

Sonnet 18: 'Shall I compare thee...'

In 'Shall I compare thee...,' Shakespeare contemplates the essence of a perfect lover, transcending the ephemeral beauty of both women and the seasons.

Sonnet 18 encapsulates a tender and affectionate mood that permeates the entire poem. The poet employs a tone of romantic intimacy as a young man expresses his fascination with a woman's beauty. This mood and tone work harmoniously to establish the poem's emotional backdrop and set the stage for its themes. In this sonnet, the poet's words eloquently convey a profound sense of admiration and affection, underscoring the enduring allure of the subject despite the inexorable march of time.

Get quality help now
Sweet V
Sweet V
checked Verified writer

Proficient in: Free Essays

star star star star 4.9 (984)

“ Ok, let me say I’m extremely satisfy with the result while it was a last minute thing. I really enjoy the effort put in. ”

avatar avatar avatar
+84 relevant experts are online
Hire writer

The audience for this sonnet is explicitly the person Shakespeare addresses, rendering it a deeply personal and realistic expression of love. The poet skillfully describes a lover 'more temperate' than a summer's day, asserting that even as external beauty fades, the inner beauty, symbolized by 'eternal summer,' remains unscathed. The immortalization of the perfect lover in a sonnet becomes a testament to enduring beauty, as expressed in the lines, 'So long live this, and this gives life to thee.

Get to Know The Price Estimate For Your Paper
Topic
Number of pages
Email Invalid email

By clicking “Check Writers’ Offers”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy policy. We’ll occasionally send you promo and account related email

"You must agree to out terms of services and privacy policy"
Write my paper

You won’t be charged yet!

'

Shakespeare's choice of the word 'temperate' implies a moderation that surpasses the fleeting brilliance of summer. It serves as a metaphor for the measured and lasting beauty that the speaker attributes to the perfect lover. The poet masterfully employs the metaphor of 'eternal summer,' suggesting a timeless and unchanging quality, an everlasting season of beauty that transcends the inevitable aging process. The act of immortalizing the beloved through poetry becomes a powerful declaration of love's ability to defy the ravages of time.

Furthermore, 'Shall I compare thee...' not only explores the theme of enduring beauty but also delves into the transformative power of poetry. The poet's assertion that the sonnet itself bestows life upon the subject elevates the art of writing to a divine level. The act of capturing the essence of the beloved in verse becomes a means of achieving immortality, as the words breathe life into the eternal summer within the sonnet.

Sonnet 116: 'Let me not'

In contrast, 'Let me not' explores the concept of ideal love in its purest form, addressing a broader audience of anyone who engages with the sonnet. This sonnet unfolds as a discourse on the unchanging nature of true love, depicted as a 'marriage of true minds.' Shakespeare emphasizes the stability of this love, resilient against alterations and challenges. The didactic tone in 'Let me not' underscores the poet's unwavering belief in a perfect love that transcends time and circumstance.

Shakespeare's use of the term 'marriage of true minds' elevates the concept of love to a union of not just bodies but also of intellects and souls. This elevated notion of love as a harmonious partnership of minds suggests a profound connection that goes beyond the physical realm. The poet's assertion that true love does not alter 'when it alteration finds' emphasizes the enduring nature of this connection, unaffected by the inevitable changes that life may bring.

'Let me not' presents an idealized vision of love that stands as an unwavering beacon in the face of life's storms. The imagery of love as an 'ever fixed mark' evokes a sense of permanence and constancy. The metaphorical comparison of love to a guiding star reinforces the idea that true love serves as a reliable and unwavering source of guidance in the tumultuous journey of life.

Structural and Stylistic Analysis

Both sonnets adhere to the Shakespearean sonnet form, comprising three quatrains followed by a rhyming couplet. This structured approach, with its regular rhythm and controlled enjambment, complements the thematic elements of the sonnets. 'Let me not' employs a rhyme scheme of A B B A, C D D C, E F F E, G G, consistent with the established Shakespearean sonnet form. The structured organization reinforces the ordered nature of the love being described in each sonnet.

The controlled structure of the sonnets mirrors the control and order that the poets assert love possesses. The deliberate use of enjambment, particularly evident in 'Let me not' on line 2 leading onto line 3, serves to maintain the orderly flow of thought while allowing for a natural and fluid expression of ideas. This deliberate choice in structure adds to the overall impact of the sonnets, underscoring the poets' command over both their craft and the subject matter.

Imagery and Symbolism

'Shall I compare thee...' is replete with imagery, particularly centered around the passage of time and the changing seasons. Shakespeare skillfully juxtaposes the fading beauty of summer with the eternal beauty of the perfect lover, immortalized through the poet's words. The repetition of the word 'faire' adds depth, signifying both a beautiful day and a beautiful woman, drawing a parallel between the transient nature of seasons and youth.

The use of the changing seasons as a metaphor for the transience of beauty adds layers of meaning to the sonnet. Summer, the epitome of beauty, is portrayed as fleeting, mirroring the fleeting nature of youth and external attractiveness. The poet's choice to explore the theme of fading beauty in the third stanza adds a poignant dimension to the sonnet, creating a sense of urgency and a call to appreciate the beauty that will inevitably diminish over time.

In 'Let me not,' the imagery revolves around the steadfastness of love. The sonnet paints a vivid picture of an unyielding love that remains unaffected by time, storms, or uncertainties. Love is portrayed as 'an ever fixed mark' and 'Time's fool,' emphasizing its timeless and unchanging nature. The comparison to a guiding star reinforces the constancy and reliability of true love.

The metaphor of love as an 'ever fixed mark' invites contemplation on the immutability of genuine affection. The sonnet suggests that, like a fixed mark, love remains resilient in the face of life's unpredictable events. The comparison to a guiding star further amplifies the idea that love serves as a guiding force, a source of unwavering support in navigating the complexities of existence.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the comparative analysis of Shakespeare's Sonnets 18 and 116 reveals a nuanced exploration of love. 'Shall I compare thee...' delves into the intricacies of a perfect lover's beauty, while 'Let me not' extols the virtues of an unalterable and ideal love. Both sonnets, despite their differences, share a common thread of lyrical beauty, structured composition, and profound insights into the complexities of human emotions. Shakespeare's timeless verses continue to resonate, inviting readers to contemplate the enduring nature of love in its various forms.

Updated: Jan 04, 2024
Cite this page

Comparative Analysis of Shakespearean Sonnets. (2016, Jul 15). Retrieved from https://studymoose.com/contrasting-sonnets-18-and-116-by-william-shakespeare-essay

Comparative Analysis of Shakespearean Sonnets essay
Live chat  with support 24/7

👋 Hi! I’m your smart assistant Amy!

Don’t know where to start? Type your requirements and I’ll connect you to an academic expert within 3 minutes.

get help with your assignment